Make a Comment 0

The Download: The birtherism of a nation

Posted in: Crime and safety   Massachusetts Legislature   Media   Current Affairs
Tags: The Download



According to a New York Times/CBS poll released last week, 25 percent of adults surveyed believe that President Obama was not born in the US. Among Republicans, the figure soars to 45 percent.

These people -- so-called “birthers” who question whether Obama was born in the United States and therefore eligible under the Constitution to serve as president -- do not seem particularly swayed by the repeated presentation of a birth certificate showing that Obama was born in Honolulu in 1961. Nor does the birth announcement printed at the time in a Honolulu newspaper do much to disabuse them of the idea Obama was born abroad, even though this requires a belief that his Kenyan father and American mother, living abroad, planted a phony announcement in a Hawaiian paper because they had a notion that their newborn biracial son might some day run for president -- in a country where, at the time, blacks were still being thwarted from even voting in states throughout the South.

If birthers can’t be persuaded by facts, it’s probably time to put them on the analyst’s couch and try to understand the persistence of this belief. That’s just what the Times did last week, when it had seven experts weigh in on its “Room for Debate” blog on the topic of “The psychology of the ‘birther’ myth.”

For various reasons, write these academics -- a mix of psychologists and political scientists -- birthers are not particularly susceptible to the logic of reasoned argument.  Nicholas DiFonzo, a psychology professor at the Rochester Institute of Technology, says the reason is the “increasingly disconnected ideological echo chambers” that dominate current political life. Those who engage only like-minded people, simply reinforce each other’s views and don’t tend to challenge false rumors about the other side, he says.

James La Plant, a political science professor at Valdosta State University in Georgia, articulates well what may be the futility of trying to refute deeply-held birther belief. “I learned long ago that you will rarely win an argument with a conspiracy theorist,” he writes. “Conspiracy theorists have a profound distrust of the media and experts of all types. What most of us would consider solid evidence to quickly dismiss these charges would be rejected by birthers as frauds, fakes or manipulated documents.” La Plant says one also has to recognize that some birthers -- he charitably pegs it as “maybe a small percentage -- are driven by “old-fashioned racial hostility.”

Finally, there is also at play an element of straightforward ignorance that goes even beyond the realm of conspiracy theory.  LaPlant says that in a 2009 poll of North Carolina voters conducted by Public Policy Polling 26 percent of respondents did not believe Obama was born in the US, while 20 percent were unsure.  “A question later in the poll asked if Hawaii was part of the United States," he writes. "5 percent of respondents said no and 3 percent were unsure.”

                                                                                                                                                                            --MICHAEL JONAS


BEACON HILL

The Salem News surveys local reps on municipal health care reform. Interestingly, Rep. Brad Hill, a Republican from Ipswich, is undecided.

The Boston Herald publishes a lineup card for the upcoming trial of former House Speaker Sal DiMasi. The trial has Howie Carr licking his chops, and the state GOP looks to make political hay out of the political star power on the trial witness lists.

MUNICIPAL MATTERS

Lawrence Mayor William Lantigua denies any wrongdoing and says he “had no idea” that either he or his administration were the targets of a federal investigation, the Eagle-Tribune reports. Meanwhile, City Councilor Grisel Silva calls on Lantigua to step aside until the investigation is completed. House Minority Leader Brad Jones wants a full accounting of how Lantigua has spent the $35 million aide package Beacon Hill sent to Lawrence last year.

Longtime Northampton mayor Clare Higgins gets kudos from the Springfield Republican as she plans to step down for a position at a nonprofit.

NATIONAL POLITICS/WASHINGTON

US Rep. Stephen Lynch explains on Keller@Large how budget cuts proposed by both Republicans and President Obama will impact the Bay State.

At the National Review, Andrew C. McCarthy says only Obama can trigger a default if Congress refuses to raise the debt ceiling, despite a growing chorus of bipartisan and nonpartisan warnings to the contrary.

And speaking of birtherism, Michael Bloomberg addresses Donald Trump, rich guy to rich guy, and urges the Donald to drop his birther shtick.

ELECTION 2012

Doug Rubin highlights cracks in Scott Brown’s armor.

The Globe profiles Bay State native Jennifer O’Malley Dillon, who will play a key role in presidential election as deputy campaign manager for President Obama’s reelection effort.

BUSINESS/ECONOMY

New IRS figures show that Americans gave about 20 percent less to charities during the 2008-2009 recession cycle than in 2007, giving nonprofits an even bigger hole to climb out of than experts predicted.

EDUCATION

Merrimack College in North Andover plans to build a sports medicine complex to complement one of its fastest-growing majors, sports medicine, the Eagle-Tribune reports.

HEALTH CARE

Paul Levy says a respected third-party should analyze global payment data rather than relying on those with vested interests before the state goes full bore with implementing the radical change.

The MetroWest Daily News voices its support for municipal health care reform.

TRANSPORTATION

The Springfield Republican compares Westfield’s Great River Bridge project to the Big Dig.

ENERGY/ENVIRONMENT

The House budget’s proposed 14 percent cut in funding for the state Department of Environmental Protection goes too far, say some, including a leading business advocate.

Trying to cut down on litter and litter removal costs, Beverly is removing all trash cans from one of its parks, the Salem News reports.

CRIMINAL JUSTICE/PUBLIC SAFETY

Most escalators at Massachusetts shopping malls are not receiving mandated annual state inspections, the Globe reports.

Bloody brawl at alcohol-fueled baby shower in Lawrence ends with three arrests, the Eagle-Tribune reports.

The Globe editorial page doesn’t like the smell of a recent Supreme Judicial Court ruling that the odor of marijuana in a car isn’t enough cause to justify further police interrogation of inspection of the vehicle.

A University of Colorado law professor argues in The New Republic that law schools dramatically inflate figures on the percentage of graduates that find employment as lawyers in the months after graduation.

MEDIA

The Outraged Liberal wants to know who’s going to cover the budget battle on Beacon Hill, fires, and fender-benders when all the local television stations and the two main newspapers send reporters, cameramen and photographers to report on the Royal Wedding.

A number of the country’s leading business schools, including Harvard, are teaching MBA candidates the ins and outs of social media as an element of success and survival.

0 Article Comments
There are currently no comments.
Would you like to comment? You must Login or Create an Account to leave a comment.
Back to top

Login

Forgot Password?

 

* = Required
*
Username Required
*
Password Required

Create an Account Here!

Create an account with us to comment on stories and blog posts. Your account information will not be shared with third parties.

* = Required
*
First Name Required
*
Last Name Required
*
Screen Name Required
*
Email Required
*
Password Required
*
Confirm Password Required
*

Archive